Back to home

More Than Pretty: The Economics and Stories of Plant Power with Charlie Hall, Blooms and Beyond, S03E01

More Than Pretty: The Economics and Stories of Plant Power with Charlie Hall

Host: Dr. Ping Yu, UGA Department of Horticulture Guest: Dr. Charlie Hall, Professor and Ellison Endowed Chair in International Floriculture, Texas A&M University Producer: Rich Braman Episode: S03E01, Blooms and Beyond, Season 3 Duration: 57:47 Air Date: November 8, 2026


Welcome

Ping Yu: Hello everyone, welcome to the Blooms and Beyond Podcast, a podcast that uncovers plant history, culture and management through the lens of science. I’m your host Ping. How’s everyone doing today? I am doing doing great because I’m very excited to have one of the icons of our industry. And now I can call m I can probably call my colleague Dr. Charlie Hall, from the Texas A&M University here with me today. And we’re going to talk about the plant power from economics benefits in the future of horticulture.

I know Charlie has tons of stories and knowledge to share so I don’t want to steal any more thunder from our speaker today. Let’s just jump right into it. Without further ado, here is my conversation with Dr. Charlie Hall. I hope you enjoy.


Meet Charlie Hall

Ping Yu: So hi Charlie, welcome to the podcast. But first let’s start off with the introduction. Can you tell our audience a little bit about who you are and what you do?

Charlie Hall: Sure, sure, absolutely. Thanks Ping for the invitation. It’s good to be here. I’m I’m flattered that I was asked to be here. So um I’m professor at Texas A&M, as you said. And holder of an endowed chair that’s called the Ellison Endowed Chair in International Floriculture. Now that’s dealing specifically with the the flower side of the business. Um of course floriculture crops, if anybody gets the USDA Floriculture Crops Report includes you know, propagative materials and potted flowering plants and and um perennials are sometimes included. But, but and cut flowers and and so forth.

But as an economist, I cover the entire industry. So it’s not just floriculture crops, it’s it’s everything, because it still comes down to jobs and it comes down to economic impact.

And that’s that’s what I’ve been doing for almost forty years. It’s thirty-eight and a half years. I think I think that’s it. Thirty almost it’s either th almost coming up on thirty eight or thirty-eight and a half. I forget, but anyway.

Ping Yu: It’s it’s too too long to remember.

Charlie Hall: Yeah.

Ping Yu: Yeah, I guess like everybody out there sh if you’re in the industry should know Charlie and I’m flattered to have him on the podcast. It’s just uh I was like, hey it, he’s the one of the like rock stars in our uh industry. I n I gotta have him. So uh…

Charlie Hall: You’re too kind.

A Sideline Nursery in Western North Carolina

Ping Yu: Uh so so Charlie, what what first sparked your interest in horticulture in general? Can you share your horticulture and career journey with us?

Charlie Hall: Yeah. Oh actually I I grew up in Western North Carolina. My father was a millwright at the Champion Paper Mill and my family had experimented in growing some strawberries and and uh so forth and so. But we got out of the strawberry business by accident and we got into the nursery business. And this was a sideline operation. Right. It’s just a sideline business. It was something for our family to do is my mom and my brother, my sister, and my dad. And we we started just potting up some plants in the backyard. And it’s not too unlike a story that you probably hear Ken Altman tell a lot that that, you know, they s he started some plants in his I think it’s his mom’s backyard and grew into Altman Plants today, you know, the big operation. Our nursery never got that big. But it started with humble beginnings, much like that.

And of course, my dad working at the paper mill, we could get truckloads of pine bark for free. And so all we had to do is go load it up. And so I spent a lot of days with a pitchfork in hand. And loading up pine bark in the back of the truck and then going home and sifting that pine bark and and getting all the lime the chunks of lime out of the pine bark. So in hindsight, a lot of the growing issues that we were having was probably because of this tainted pine bark that we were using. But it was free.

And and so we would recycle our our pots and and we would propagate into ground beds and we would cover those with little mini hoop houses during the winter. And and so we would do our own propagation, we’d do our own planting, and we would um we would sell mostly to garden garden centers and landscapers, a lot of landscapers there locally.

And w you know, we didn’t know pricing. We basically sold our plants cheap and therefore we got a lot of c business because of that. And uh so yeah, those are my early beginnings with the the nursery back in western North Carolina.

Learning to Price Plants

Ping Yu: Yeah, so you basically start with the start strictly within the industry. So to the point where you didn’t know the uh price of the plant you sold it on cheap, that that um, trigger you, uh, the…

Charlie Hall: Well we knew what everybody else was charging and and Dad figured if we just charged a little bit less that would increase the demand, which I mean there was some merit to that. But it it wasn’t as though we were using a cost based strategy where we were looking at what it cost us and using that as the as the floor for our price and in the willingness to pay, using that as the the top side of the ceiling of the price.

No, we didn’t have anything nearly that complex. It was: all right, here’s the all the catalogs we picked up at the trade show and and here’s an average of those catalogs and we need to be slightly below the average to so that where demand would be high.

Well, we didn’t know that, you know, the industry was growing at double digit rates back then. We g we could have raised our price and still probably had plenty of folks show up to buy our by our plants. But, you know, you know we learned some valuable lessons.

And it’s no longer in business. So that tum to me that’s the, to the the listeners that are online, that’s the number one lesson. You price your plants too cheap, you go out of business. That’s that’s…

Ping Yu: You better do your homework now.

Charlie Hall: Do the homework. Push the pencil, exactly.

Ping Yu: Yeah, yeah.


Finding Horticultural Economics

Ping Yu: So it that exper that that experience actually puts your uh kind of get you the interest of studying uh economics specifically in horticulture?

Charlie Hall: Well um in that, that interest started a little bit later. I mean it at least exposed me to horticulture, but ironically, as I was growing up, I kind of resented all the time I had to spend working in the nursery. ’cause it took time away from my t my two favorite pastimes, which was sports and girls. So I…

Ping Yu: Yeah, sure. Yes.

Charlie Hall: But I c I came full circle and when I was uh as an undergrad at the University of Tennessee, I took a farm management class and we had to do a whole farm plan. And since I knew the nursery business somewhat, I used our nursery as a model for this farm plan that I had to do as a classroom assignment. And I made a really good grade on it. So I thought, wow, this is this is pretty cool. I can incorporate some of the things I know about the nursery business. And and get this ag economics degree. And I guess that’s where I firstly developed that that interest in both economics and horticulture at the same time. And it served me well for many, many decades.

Economics as a Way to Tell the Plant Story

Ping Yu: Now. Yeah, yeah, because I think that’s just uh the the magic the perfect marriage between the economic and plant and horticulture as horticulture as the industry in general. We are underappreciated and under represented uh represented. So uh as a economic uh uh as a economic uh specialist, how do you when do you realize that, it could economic could be a powerful tool to tell the story of the plant and their value?

Charlie Hall: That’s a that’s a great question. Uh of course my master’s degree was in horticulture because I had uh a horticulture minor as I was getting my ag economics undergrad, and one of my professors said, hey, you should, you should go on for a master’s degree in horticulture before you go out in industry and combine the economic language and principles with the horticulture language and principles, and we need more people like that. So you’d be satisfying a niche and so it sounded like a good idea.

I I was I was going to to get my master’s in horticulture and go out in the industry and and make my millions, you know, I was gonna I was gonna be rich and famous. I could drive a Porsche and so forth. And as many tongue in cheek as many nursery operators do. What I found is uh I kind of like that research a little bit.

And indeed my major professor when I was finishing up my horticulture degree, he said, you know what? You got the gift of B. S. You need to go on for a PhD. So I kid you not. I’ve I’ve I said, that sounds pretty good.

And and so I went from one mentor at the University of Tennessee down to another mentor at Mississippi State. I didn’t even have to take the GRE. Yeah, this was back in the day. They said, hey, come on down, we’ll we’ll put you together a an assistantship. Get you started working here in the nursery area and doing your uh dissertation and now economics on on nursery crops. And so lo and behold, that’s what I did. I developed a linear programming model to optimize profitability given labor constraints and and resource constraints like water, etc. So it was it was a pretty good experience because I was looking at nursery production from a sequential standpoint and look I knew costs for producing nursery crops like the back of my hand. So it was…

And and really, Ping, it it was a springboard because the at the time the S-103 committee, the multi-state uh research committee uh was in full bore and I mean there were a lot of notor uh, there’s a lot of notoriety on that S-103 committee. Everybody that did everything in economics and horticulture was on that committee and so I said, I gotta be on that committee.

And and so um I got my job here at Texas A&M back in nineteen eighty eight and and so joined the S-103 committee. But that committee’s changed numbers over time. But we still have horticulturists and ag economists on that same committee. Now there are few who are truly horticultural economists like myself.

Ping Yu: Yeah.

Charlie Hall: Yeah. That have been trained in both areas, but at least we have representation of both.

And I and I’ll say this, I you referred to me as a rock star early on, and I you know, I I really attribute my success to the fact that I can I can tell an economic story that’s that sounds pretty good and I can make it humorous at the same time. So I that, that’s part of my success is my ability to speak and explain concepts. But remember, I’ve I’m I’m just a a country boy. I’m just trying to explain economics in a way that I can understand it. And it just so happens people like the way that I explain it. So it’s worked out pretty good because of that.

But there’s some young people coming on. Yeah, they got uh Alicia Rihn at Tennessee, got Melinda Knuth at NC State, Hayk Khachatryan at Florida, Ben Campbell at uh uh Georgia with his wife Julie. At Georgia as well. Ariana Torres at Purdue. I mean we we have some I shouldn’t have listed people ‘cause now the th there’s a f Marco Palma here at Texas A&M, there’s a bunch of people that have forgotten more economics than I ever knew. They’re so talented in and I’m very optimistic in terms of the future of the industry and the the economic research and the consumer behavior research that’s going to be conducted over the next decade, next three decades probably.

And but with because these these these younger faculty have so much more talent than I ever dreamed of. I mean it’s it’s truly amazing some of the folks. And, you know, even yourself the horticulture side of things, you’re already making a name for yourself in the industry.

So I’m I’m very bullish on the green industry in the future in terms of our research capabilities, even though, you know, funding is still always an issue and we don’t have as nearly as many faculty positions as what what we used to have. But what we do have is really high quality researchers who are collaborating more than what we did back then because to get a federal grant, you’ve got to have everybody that’s anybody working on a on an idea. You gotta have them working together. And so, but that way we all work together and get the money, whereas if we were trying to compete against each other, none of us would get it probably.

So it’s it’s you know I’m I’m kind of bouncing around here, but I’m I’m just saying that our industry from a research perspective, I think has a bright future ahead of it.

A Second Interview

Ping Yu: Yeah, yeah. And uh I I don’t know if you know this Charlie. This is actually the second time I interview uh with you. The first time was in Texas A&M uh and not when I was a graduate student there. I was attending one of the English writing or grant writing class and I I emailed you and say, Hey Charlie ‘cause you back then you got a you got a pretty big grant. I’m like, can I sit down with you and then ask you some questions about uh grant writing for the assignments? And you you did. And then this will be the second one.

I want to learn from you. One would be the store storytelling capability in our industry especially. We need more of that. Um, especially delivering the right or the benefits or the plant power to the larger audience, even the call uh policymakers, the the general public, to know that our industry is really contributing a lot, way more than they imagine just walking randomly into a garden center grab grab a plant. That’s it. No, it’s way more than that. Well, sometimes we need to put some uh spotlight to our industry to what we do so that people would know more.

Charlie Hall: Well historically we’ve not done enough to really brag on ourselves as an industry, but fortunately the medical industry and the psychological industry um have have done a lot of research to benefit us and we didn’t have to pay for it so it’s all even better.


What Policymakers Don’t Know

Ping Yu: So what kind of con uh misconceptions do policymakers or the general public have about the economic impact of horticulture?

Charlie Hall: Well I don’t know if it’s uh misperceptions. I just think that they don’t know, right? Because we we all know what we know uh and we don’t know what we don’t know.

Well I don’t think a lot of policymakers understand the economic significance of the green industry. And, uh, I mean the the total economic contributions from our last survey, and we just finished this up, around five hundred and fifty billion dollars.

Well back in 2005 when Alan Hodges from University of Florida and John Haydu from the University of Florida and myself, and we first did the the ver the truly the very first economic impact analysis on the green industry, we found that it’s $164 billion at that time that’s 2005 so fast forward 20 years later now we’re talking about 550 billion. So in spite of the fact that i in terms of economic contributions, not sales, but I’m talking about economic contributions from growers service providers like landscape contractors and so forth and then also the retail. And of course retail not only includes retail garden centers but includes box stores and uh mass mass merchandisers of several different types now. So we have a lot more venues to sell our plants than than what we used to.

So I think, Ping, if if I could characterize the main hurdle that we face. It’s just the fact that policymakers don’t understand the extent of our contributions. It’s not just about the economic contributions. But it’s about the ecosystem services benefits that are provided, and then also the health and well-being benefits.

And so, but, but it still comes down to economics because even though we we we talk about plants being pretty, for example, and and they are. And but the aesthetics is a value proposition that only takes us so far as an industry. We gotta talk about other things.

And from an economic standpoint, I usually talk more about pro uh property values and how property uh values are enhanced whenever there’s green spaces around them or in them, using biophilic design principles. Green roofs, green walls, natural lighting, etc. So there’s those, there are those economic benefits.

Green Infrastructure and Stormwater

Charlie Hall: But particularly in the northeast and around the I think it was the the hypersensitivity around the Chesapeake Bay watershed that really promulgated a lot of green infrastructure being planted. When they would talk about gray infrastructure and p additional piping and so forth to handle stormwater uh runoff, which was one of the c most costly expenditures that cities can make is is mitigating stormwater runoff. They have all this redundant piping and s uh s uh stu sewer systems, etcetera. And that’s a lot of money is invested in that gray infrastructure, but you could take a fraction of that cost and invest it in green infrastructure, slow down the water, keep part of it in the tree canopy so that the tree releases it slowly, more of the water can percolate through the soil and less of it run off, so you have less of a need to to to basically put in a lot of gray and redundant infrastructure and put in more green infrastructure.

So th that’s has really led to a whole branch of economics uh within the resource economics purview, of trying to monetize what that green infrastructure does for us. And in terms of the the mitigating stormwater runoff or reducing erosion or removing the contaminants that go down into aquifers, that we can we can uh filter the water uh before it even gets there. Or we can uh filter the f the particulates that are in the air that caused a lot of upper respiratory diseases across the country and a lot of uh r heart-related chronic diseases as well from just breathing bad air. And trees help remove those particulates from the air.

So that then that’s a segue into the the savings and the health costs. And people are b better fit, they’re they’re they’re more active if they have if green spaces are are close in proximity. Right? If they the closer they are to a green space, the more likely people are to engage in it and uh and it affects their health.

The Boot Camp That Saved His Life

Charlie Hall: Ev- even myself, my wife and I were doing a boot camp. But just just just like you can imagine a boot camp in the army. This this was a boot camp and it it was a workout boot camp and we would flip tires and we would beat on them with sledgehammers and we would uh belly crawl through the grass. I mean we it was it was a lot of fun.

But it was because of that boot camp that saved my life because when my heart rate would go up a certain uh level, it felt like a big weight was on my chest and it was trying to figure out what that was that that ultimately led to a quadruple bypass. Yeah, because three of my arteries and my heart were clot seventy-five percent clogged and one of them was ninety-nine percent clogged.

And so had I not been active in that boot camp, which was in a park here locally in College Station, had I not done that, I would have been at some meeting do doing a keynote and probably uh had a massive heart attack and kicked a bucket.

So it I th I I attribute green spaces to actually saving my life. And um and and I therefore I’m just on a mission to help other people understand exactly what the economic, environmental, and health and well-being benefits are.


Telling the Story of Plants

Ping Yu: From your experience, how we as scientists as the industry, how can we better tell the story to the general public and the policymakers to, you know, brag about our industry?

Charlie Hall: Yeah. Well part of it is monetizing it and getting folks to understand that economic value. But that’s that’s really not the answer. Even though I’m an economist and saying this.

To me, the answer goes back to a word that you used earlier in a storytelling. See, I I just told you how green spaces improved my own health by helping me realize that there were some heart issues that I had to to deal with.

His Father and Dementia

Charlie Hall: But I’ve also had several other circumstances in my life, like my father passed away with dementia. And I know that a lot of people have to deal with dementia and Alzheimer’s disease in their families.

And some of the benefits that we’ve seen is when dementia and Alzheimer’s patients are in green spaces, their memory retention is enhanced by as much as twenty percent. And and the the…

I I remember m my dad because of this particular disease hardly resembled the same man that I grew up with who was c cracking jokes and so forth. But he became, you know, angry and belligerent and and it’s just not even the same man. But we could get that outside potting up a plant. You know, just repotting a house plant. Now remember, this is going all the way back to our nursery days, right?

Ping Yu: Yeah.

Charlie Hall: Hands in the dirt. And so when when th when dad was outside potting up a plant or just being outside, he was more like the old dad again.

So the I’ve seen the power that plants have on the both the cognitive ability and the mental acuity uh that individuals have as they age then there there are tremendous benefits.

Well, I could have just told you that that um that when you have healing gardens at hospitals that or Alzheimer’s clinics or dementia clinics, that it it’s beneficial for the patients and it’s it’s beneficial for the staff. There’s less turnover by the staff, be because of the green spaces, the healing gardens. Well, th I could tell you those things, but for me to tell my story about my own father is more powerful.

And I think people relate to stories. That’s how uh just think about for thousands of years, that’s the only way we transferred knowledge through time is we told stories. And people learn from those stories and added their own stories. And then we uh obviously we developed our our capabilities and research and we can do a lot more sophisticated consumer behavior, but it still comes down to the stories. Right.

ADHD, School Gardens, and Bullying

Charlie Hall: And so how many moms are out there across the country that are dealing with kids with ADHD. Right? And so we w back in my day, we just thought that that the kids were overactive or they had too much sugar or what have you. And we yelled at them to try to keep them in control. But now we understand there’s a we have an understanding that there’s a physiological response that’s happening in the body. And perhaps a chemical imbalance of s of one sort that’s causing those behaviors.

But if a kid’s outside for 20 minutes in an improved landscape, it has the same effect neurologically as two of their medications. So again, there’s there’s tremendous value in, and to society because we deal with that all the time.

In childhood obesity, the schools with school gardens have a lower incidence of childhood obesity and and get this there’s fewer instances of bullying in schools that have school gardening programs than schools that don’t have them.

So these are societal issues that we’re wrestling with that that directly affect the quality of our lives. And so what we’re talking about is the quality of their life being positively impacted by their proximity to green spaces or being involved in gardening or landscaping or potting up a plant, planting a bean seed as as we do in kindergarten. Yeah. Those are things that are are influencing society.

But most people I’m not just talking about policymakers. I’m just talking about people it in general. They don’t have as much appreciation for what we do because we haven’t told the stories. We gotta keep telling the stories.

Horticultural Therapy

Ping Yu: Yeah, that’s that’s actually one of the reasons why I am so passionate with this podcast because I’m hope I’m hoping gradually we can um get the message delivered so that people would at least appreciate more about the plant. And next time they saw a plant’s not just a pretty plant. It has so much more layers to it.

And what you described is actually it’s a, it’s a discipline, it’s a research field. It we we call horticulture therapy. And it yeah, we we need to deliver more or tell more story of that so people would understand a little bit more and reason it more.

Charlie Hall: Yeah, very much so. In fact our newest certification in the department horticultural sciences here at Texas A&M is going to be horticultural therapy.

Ping Yu: Yeah, yeah. Georgia uh UGA also has one. Um so…

The Story That Resonates Most

Ping Yu: But with you you kind of briefly mentioned a little bit. You are you have been the keynote speaker for I don’t know how many industry events for how many years. Um and you have deeply involved with the industry for decades. How when you deliver the message, can you share a story, keynote story where the audience resonated the most?

Charlie Hall: Every time I talk about dementia and Alzheimer’s and I mention my father, I always have three, four, five people come up at the end and say, Thank you for telling us that story. I too had a father or mother who dealt with dementia and Alzheimer’s. So that has been one of the the facts that I talk about that resonates perhaps the best.

But then there’s there’s also, uh whene whenever I get to talking about the school gardening programs, that that also causes people to to stand up and take notice and I’ve had growers hear that talk and then go to their school school boards uh yeah the and talk about we need more school garden programs. And I’ll donate plants if if we do this.

So I know that there’s some communities that now have school gardening programs because somebody heard me talk about that benefit and decided that’s what they’re going to do.

And um so I think that once people hear stories, that then they don’t forget it, right? It’s like it’s like uh we may hear a lot of statistics day in and day out. But it’s till we hear the stories about what’s going on, that’s what causes action.

This is where I hope that some of these these life-changing stories will resonate to the point where it it causes people to act.


The Pandemic Lift and a New Normal

Ping Yu: Uh so with your uh years of experience in the in industry have you seen the shift, um how consumer view plants today compared to let’s say maybe twenty, thirty years ago, where they kind of stay the same?

Charlie Hall: That’s a great question. Before the pandemic, I would have said the my answer to that question, no, I don’t see much change. I I’m standing on my soapbox and I’m I’m giving all these these speeches and I don’t see a lot of movement.

But during the pandemic when COVID was forcing us to shelter in place, what we saw is that the spending on landscape services went up. The do-it-yourself spending on gardening and landscaping supplies, it went up markedly.

So I know that that we as an industry ha benefited from people sheltering in place and spending more time at their at their homes because they looked at the walls. And they said, I need to paint this room, right? And so you saw home improvement expenditures increase. Well, landscaping was one of those home improvement expenditures. People looked outside their their y window and said, geez, my landscape sucks. I gotta do something to make this better. If I’m gonna spend so much time here, I don’t want it looking this way.

So they invested. And and so what we saw the the sales increased during the pandemic.

Every Downturn Since 1948

Charlie Hall: And ironically, not ironically, amazingly, that’s the appropriate descriptor here, is that in every economic downturn since nineteen forty eight, when people stayed at home more, we always spent more on gardening and landscaping.

But here’s the thing, Ping, is that when the recovery would start and they would start buying cars and refrigerators and clothes again, we would go through recession and we would take it on the chin, and our sales would drop back down to where they were and then we would start growing slowly again.

But what we’ve seen this time around is that we had an increase, the lift during the pandemic, and we’ve plateaued. But we have not gone back to where we were in 2019. So it’s almost like we’re at a different level now, a different level of understanding.

And and during the pandemic, I mean I had a lot of requests for information from the media. I mean, there are a lot of people saying, Charlie, what in the world is going on? Why are people spending more money? And I said, this stay-at-home effect and the influence that it had uh in previous downturns.

And the question is whether it’s gonna, you know, go back to trend or whether we’re gonna have be on a new level. Well, right as of right now, we haven’t gone back to trend.

So I think some of that information that the that the papers and the media was talking about during the pandemic, we’ve done a a better job of talking about the benefits, and I think that we’ve influenced the elasticity of demand, as we would call it, from an economics point of view. And we’ve made a difference there. We’re at a new normal, but again, we’ve plateaued. We’re not growing, but just very, very, very slowly during this time period. But we’re still a lot better off than where we were in 2019.

A lot of people get into it during the pandemic, I’m sure there were a lot of people I gotta get the kids outside this house or I’m gonna I wanna I’m gonna go stir crazy. And so they started a little garden or what have you, but they quickly realized, I mean, there’s some sweat equity that goes into that, which means that you’re getting some green exercise, right? So you’re you’re you’re getting that and and plus you’re getting some com some cross-generational interactions between the parents and the kids.

Community Gardens in Philadelphia

Charlie Hall: And and community gardens, the uh city of Philadelphia. They now here’s another interesting story is that the city of Philadelphia that doesn’t buy as many police cars or hire as many police people as what they did 30 years ago because they’ve invested so heavily in green infrastructure and a lot of the vacant lots they put in either pocket parks or community gardens.

And so those community gardens people from all generations, all ethnicities would come together, and they’re they have more eyes on the street. So the incidence of of um violent crimes all the way down to the incidents of graffiti that go way down whenever there’s community gardens in an area.

So again, a very powerful testament to the fact that there’s less crime that’s committed.

Prison Gardens and the Junior Master Gardener Program

Charlie Hall: But hi on the flip side of that coin, it’s just say that those those prisons that have prison gardening programs.

Ping Yu: Mm-hmm. Yeah.

Charlie Hall: Where the where they either grow food for the prison or it’s it’s a it’s a job training shop that they go through at the prison, those prisons with horticultural programs have lower recidivism rates. Which means the likelihood of people going back to prison once they’re released goes way down.

And I I’ve seen this myself. There’s a a program over at the Federal Men’s Prison. Um and a lot of those graduates of that horticultural program own businesses in Houston now. They own their own business. So they didn’t have to resort to getting back to a life of crime. Now they had a way of of developing um, you know, a skill set that they could use so they don’t have to go back to prison.

Now in the Junior Master Gardener program. The International Junior Master Gardener Program was started by Lisa Whittlesey at the Federal Women’s, uh, prison in Bryan, Texas. She started a guar a program, horticultural program for the women there, and it was very successful. But when their kids would come and visit them, this is this is a low security federal women’s prison, Bryan, Texas. When their kids would come to visit, they didn’t have anything to do. So they started gardening with the kids, and that was the impetus behind the International Junior Master Gardener program.

It’s just amazing to hear some of the stories. Again, it’s the stories that resonate.

Ping Yu: Yeah, the the that’s that’s all the plant power that we are talking about and we need to spread that to a wider uh audience. Sure.


Industry, Academia, and the Consumer

Ping Yu: So with your involvement with the industry for decades, have you seen any change between the relationship of uh the industry and academia, especially from the research perspective?

Charlie Hall: Well, some of the things that we work on um have changed. I mean, it used to be uh from a horticultural standpoint, it was all about the physiologically uh physi physiology of the plant. And making sure that we’re growing it in the right environment and that does and controlling this particular pest, you know, this disease, this insect, and so forth.

And all that is still important, but just the nature of what, um, I do from an uh economics and some of the people I mentioned earlier. What what there’s been more consumer behavior research. And uh a lot of that was ’cause of pioneers like Dr. Bridget Behe from Michigan State. Just a true pioneer.

She was a horticulturist, but I would I would put her in the category of of a honorary economist because she’d, she did a lot of economic related stuff in doing consumer behavior research and she’s you know renowned for that research and using technology like eye tracking equipment and biometrics equipment.

Stated Versus Revealed Preferences

Charlie Hall: And so we don’t have to necessarily rely on people giving us their stated preferences. You know, when we survey people and they say that will you be likely more more likely to buy a plant for if it’s from Georgia, right? You wanna buy a Georgia, is it the Georgia Gold is the promotional program?

Ping Yu: Georgia Grown.

Charlie Hall: Okay, all right.

So are you more likely to buy a plant from Georgia because of this program? And they’ll say, Yeah, oh absolutely. I’m a Bulldog. I’m Georgia through and through.

And and so, but that’s a stated preference versus a revealed preference is when we we go and measure um through independent means whether or not they actually buy it and whether that translates um into a purchase.

So we can we can do that through eye tracking equipment, biometrics equipment, doing experimental auctions. There’s a lot of technologies that, you know, many of the folks I talked about, includ and also Chengyan Yue, who is from uh Minnesota, she’s the Bachman chair up there. She’s also done a lot of work in this area and experimental auctions was one of the first of auctions that were were done were in the horticulture area because of some of the work that we did. So yeah, that research is changing.

What Growers Ask Privately

Ping Yu: Yeah, so what about some questions? What questions do industry need or ask you more very often privately, not on stage? Do you get any of those?

Charlie Hall: I I get a lot of those. Remember I have the EAGL program, which is the Executive Academy for Growth and Leadership, and it’s like an executive MBA for nursery and greenhouse growers. And from that, there’s a spin-off program called Your Market Metrics. And it’s all about the financial and operational ratios that that really um are a measurement of how well we’re doing in our business.

So I get a lot more questions about the financial state of the business. And and what should my ratios look like? Uh what should my performance compared to other people? What does it look like? And so I started those programs several years ago. So yeah, I get asked a lot of questions, but a lot of those tend to be financially related.

And people want to know when I say, when I stand up at the stage at Cultivate. And I tell growers you gotta do three things, right? You gotta you gotta manage your working capital, right? You gotta push the pencil a little harder and and you’ve got to um develop a value proposition that resonates with your customer base. Right. When I when I say those kind of things, they want to know what do you mean by value proposition? What how do I manage my working capital? How do I make sure I’ve got enough cash?

So then, that’s that’s a teachable moment. And and then I can use some of the the either the research that I’ve done here at Texas A&M or the through the EAGL program and the Your Market Metrics program, I can I can go and I can give them real numbers on how to do that.

Where the Industry Underinvests

Ping Yu: So are there any area that uh where the industry uh underinvestigate investing economically speaking?

Charlie Hall: Underinvesting? Yeah. Well, we’ve already talked about some of it. It’s the promotional aspects of the benefits. All right. We’re definitely underinvesting there. Remember, we didn’t have to pay for a lot of that. The medical profession paid for it. Or the psychological profession paid for it. But we need to to market the message better than what we are. There’s no doubt about that.

But do you do that as the individual firm level or do you do that in an industry level? The there’s people that contend all we need is a big generic promotion pro prom promotional program like Got Milk or beef what’s for dinner or the the orange juice pro the uh promotional program and they said then then we’ll have it made.

But really, most of my experience shows that those programs only are good while they’re going on. You take Got milk. Excuse me. You got milk, for example. Milk consumption today is lower than what it was prior to the Got Milk program.

So we didn’t change long-term drinking behavior of milk one bit. But while the program was existing, yeah, we had a higher level of per capita consumption.

So it’s the same way with any generic advertising program. To me, it’s better for individual firms to build this into their sales and their marketing messages. And if everybody in the industry with big big pie of everybody in the industry was incorporating these sales and marketing messages then we’d ha we’d have more of an impact.

So we we gotta have a value proposition of more than pretty. That’s and that’s I’ve said that several times on the stage there at Cultivate and other places.


Opportunities: Climate, Data, and AI

Ping Yu: With your experience, what do you see as the biggest oppor opportunity for our growing industry right now?

Charlie Hall: Well we have so many. And and one of those is uh just start with climate change, for example.

One of those is to to remind people that we’re part of the answer for some of the issues that we’re wrestling with because of climate change. All the flooding that goes on and remember the stormwater mitigation that I was talking about earlier. Well, an investment in green infrastructure will help uh any of those negative consequences from from flooding. May help it uh prevent flooding, period.

So that’s that’s one thing is we have an underinvestment of that type of research and implementation.

Big Data and AI

Charlie Hall: But but also uh we need more investment into tools that’ll help us manage the data.

Now we we have some some ERP systems, for example, enterprise resource planning systems, the big software packages that growers and other people use. We we have ERP systems, but they’re they’re almost too siloed. They they almost we don’t share enough data across those systems to be able to make more informed decisions across all areas of the business or all areas across the industry.

So we need more of an investment in managing big data and utilizing AI as part of that analysis of that of those data. So it again, AI is much more than ChatGPT and so forth.

And the last two reunion meetings of my EAGL cohorts, we’ve had a big strong focus on AI and how do we best utilize that. And so, um there’s tremendous applications in terms of developing our sales and our production plans, allocating space um our sales messaging. Uh there’s a lot of applications, but we’ve only scratched the surface in terms of how AI is going to influence the industry.

So we’ve we’ve underinvested in that category, but it’s, that we’ll change that.

You got HRI leadership um is has recognized that AI is going to be important. And so they’re trying to allocate more grant dollars from uh from HRI in those categories.

Plants Versus Pills

Ping Yu: Yeah, yeah. But so looking ahead, let’s say ten to twenty years. What what’s what’s your vision for our green industry?

Charlie Hall: Yeah, I my vision, my, my big hairy audacious goal for the industry would be for us to to get to a point where we don’t have to persuade people that green spaces are beneficial to them and that by then people prefer plants versus pills.

And that by then green spaces will be a necessity in people’s lives rather than being considered a luxury that they can cast aside whenever there’s a downturn and so forth.

So that any project, any government project or any private project, any construction project at all has to have a green component to it. What’s the, the green infrastructure that’s going to go on in this project? We, we get to a point where that people don’t even have to think about whether or not to make that purchase. It’s just going to be a part of natural everyday behaviors.

Just like, you know, buying chocolate on Valentine’s Day or or buying roses or or buying uh bread and milk and so forth for the week that buying plants becomes just a standard practice.

It’s what we do. That’s how we survive. That’s how we influence the the life, the the quality of our lives through all those different constructs that I was talking about earlier.

Ping Yu: Yeah, I think that would be some of i that would be my ideal scenario too as and where for any given horticulture or people in the um green industry uh would love to say people just uh um see plants as essential um daily um goods, just like milk and egg.


Two Ears, One Mouth

Ping Yu: So what um with your experience and knowledge, uh what kind of um skills that you would help everyone in this green industry, especially those young professionals, including uh researchers and those young professionals in the industry uh to have?

Charlie Hall: Well, uh that’s an interesting story. I mean, there, there’s a lot of skills that are needed. Yeah, I already talked about AI skills, supply chain logistics. I mean there are a lot of different skills.

But I perhaps the greatest single skill that I’ve relied on my entire career is the fact that I have two ears and one mouth. And it may be hard to believe, but I try to use them in that proportion.

And the the biggest, most impactful programs, whether it be a research program or an outreach program, because I’ve I’ve been research teaching and extension for a long time. But the most impactful programs have been those that I heard someone state the issue and then I asked the questions to clarify the issue and then I built teams that could come together with different skills that I didn’t have to do everything, but my, I’m a good listener. And I I’m a I’m an okay speaker, right? I got some speaking skills.

Ping Yu: You’re a great speaker.

Charlie Hall: But my my biggest claim to fame is being able to put teams together and teams of very talented people who are much smarter than me and get a little bit of money so that we can do the research.

That’s been my my single greatest contribution is being able to combine those skills.

It’s not necessarily my economic prowess. It’s not necessarily my my speaking ability, but it’s my ability to to use those two ears versus my one mouth.

And then translate that into a researchable issue, put teams together to address those issues, and then disseminate the impacts. You gotta you gotta talk about it. You gotta tell the stories.

And so that’s one thing that I hope, you know, I’ll be retiring in eighteen months.

Ping Yu: No way. Really?

Charlie Hall: Yeah. Now I’m not going away. I’m just gonna be retiring from Texas A&M. I’ll still do my EAGL program and Your Market Metrics and speaking and so forth.

But, uh that’s one thing I hope my legacy is demonstrating to junior faculty the importance of collaboration, that it’s not it’s not all about the accolades or the uh the awards those will come naturally when you when you do impactful stuff, those you get recognized for it.

But you only want to really make a deep impact is by working together with other talented people instead of the you know developing such uh a uniqueness on your own part. That that’ll get you far, but it’s not going to get you as far as what you would than collaborating.

So that’s to me that’s that’s the greatest skill that I can help impart on up-and-coming faculty.

Ping Yu: I think that’s a that that’s the essential skill, um especially for now.

Where to Find Charlie Hall

Ping Yu: So with that in mind if, if people want to get a hold of you or stay tuned of your um work, where do you recommend them go and look for those information?

Charlie Hall: Yeah, yeah. Well, they can Google Charlie Hall, Texas A&M. It’s the first thing that pops up. It’s searching in search engine optimization. That’s we taught that for so many years. And my website is the ellisonchair.tamu.edu.

That’s that’s where a lot of the benefits information is. There’s a special section there for the benefits of plants and green spaces. I always say that’s a nice clearinghouse of information, a good place to start. Because I don’t just have my own information, I’ve got a lot of other people’s information on there as well. So that’s probably the best place.

Ping Yu: Okay, I’ll make sure that I put uh all those links in on the show notes so people can find those information very easily.

But thank you, Charlie, uh for taking time out of your busy schedule to talk with us. I, like always, I always enjoy talking with you and see you at uh conference and uh thank you for making the big difference in our industry and giving the opportunity advocate for um our the the next generation of research uh researchers and professionals to our industry.

I just think that um, our industry is just so lucky to have you for those many years and continue.

Charlie Hall: Thank you very much, Ping. You’re too kind and I appreciate the invitation to come and and be on the podcast today. And uh look forward to future collaborations.


Closing

Ping Yu: Conversation like this only happen when you support the show. For more information and find ways to support us, please go to bandbpod.com. bandbpod.com.

If you like what you are hearing, spread the word and share this podcast with the people you love. Make sure you hit that subscription button and give a review for the podcast. And as always, go check out the show notes to learn more about this topic and other topics we featured on the show at bandbpod.com.

Thank you for listening. Till the next time, stay healthy and go plants!


Transcript produced for Blooms and Beyond / UGA Center for Urban Agriculture